Hierarchical Feedback Distortion
Date of Addition
5 March 2025
The Hierarchical Feedback Distortion Principle operates through a specific mechanism wherein state and central governments respond dramatically to negative feedback, often through public statements, high-profile investigations, or policy announcements. These responses, while highly visible, frequently fail to address the underlying structural issues that enable corruption or administrative failures at the local level. The resulting dynamic creates what can be described as "accountability gaps" – spaces within the governance system where certain actors can operate with relative impunity despite the appearance of oversight.
These accountability gaps form through several interconnected processes. First, the distance between higher levels of government and local administration creates information asymmetries, where central authorities lack detailed knowledge of ground-level operations. Second, the emphasis on negative feedback creates incentives for performative responses that satisfy public demand for action without necessarily changing administrative practices. Third, the hierarchical nature of bureaucratic systems often shields lower-level officials from direct accountability to citizens, instead making them primarily answerable to superiors within the bureaucracy.
In the Indian context, these dynamics are particularly pronounced due to the country's complex multi-level governance structure, which includes central, state, district, and local administrative tiers. Each level operates with different incentives, capacities, and relationships to citizens, creating multiple opportunities for accountability mechanisms to break down. The resulting system can inadvertently create protected spaces where corruption can flourish despite the appearance of active governance and oversight from above.
This principle was created as a matter of inspiration of some of the posts by Pseudokanada, i.e., @hestmatematik on X.
terms of use
This glossary of terms is provided as a free resource for educational and informational purposes only. By using this glossary developed by Indic Pacific Legal Research LLP (referred to as 'The Firm'), you agree to the following terms of use:
-
You may use the glossary for personal and non-commercial purposes only. If you use any content from the glossary of terms on this website in your own work, you must properly attribute the source. This means including a link to this website and citing the title of the glossary.
-
Here is a sample format to cite this glossary (we have used the OSCOLA citation format as an example):
Indic Pacific Legal Research LLP, 'The Indic Pacific Glossary of Terms' (Indic Pacific Legal Research, 2023) <https://www.indicpacific.com/glossary>
-
You are not authorised to reproduce, distribute, or modify the glossary without the express written permission of a representative of Indic Pacific Legal Research.
-
The Firm makes no representations or warranties about the accuracy or completeness of the glossary. The glossary is provided on an "as is" basis and the Firm disclaims all liability for any errors or omissions in the glossary.
-
You agree to indemnify and hold the Firm harmless from any claims or damages arising out of your use of the glossary.
If you have any questions or concerns about these terms of use, please contact us at global@indicpacific.com